Democrat Peltola Wins Alaska Senate Seat

The last seat in the US Senate to be decided was Alaska’s, and Democrat Mary Peltola won it with 50.1% of the vote to Republican Dan Sullivan’s 45.8%. Under the ranked choice voting system (a version of the single transferable vote) used in Alaska, there was no need to redistribute ballots of other candidates because Ms. Peltola topped 50%. Democrats now have 56 seats in the US Senate, if one includes independents Angus King of Maine and Bernie Sanders of Vermont who caucus with the Democrats. That could have interesting repercussions if the Democratic leader of the Senate, whoever that turns out to be, has any guts.

As CNN noted, Ms. Peltola held “Alaska’s at-large House seat from 2022 to 2025, serving as the state’s first Native American elected to Congress. While she lost reelection in 2024 to Republican Nick Begich, she significantly outperformed her party’s performance in the presidential election that year.” In other words, she knew Alaska because she had won statewide previously. A good candidate in a wave election won a seat that should probably not have gone to the Democrats.

The Republicans ran incumbent Dan S. Sullivan for the seat. Being a member of the ruling party at a time of anti-incumbency was a huge disadvantage for him. He also ran a rather boneheaded race. The National Republican Senate Committee website says, “Dan S. Sullivan’s Senate campaign focuses heavily on putting Alaska First by continuing the Alaska Comeback, lowering costs and taxes, and protecting Alaskans’ healthcare. Sullivan has spent his career fighting for Alaska families, and his 2026 campaign is built on delivering real results on the issues that matter most to everyday Alaskans.”

Lowering costs and taxes sounds great, but if one has been the incumbent for 12 years, the question really is “why haven’t you done this already?” Running on the Trumpist record was not wise.

The GOP also whined that there was some chicanery that could have cost them the seat. A fellow by the name of Dan J. Sullivan also ran for the seat, allegedly at the behest of the Peltola campaign. They claim that he split their vote by confusing Alaskans over which of the Dan Sullivan’s was the incumbent. The fact is that the ballot had Dan S. Sullivan listed as both the Republican candidate and as the incumbent. If one could read, one would not be confused.

More to the point, the ranked choice voting system rendered the whole question moot. If a voter was unsure which Mr. Sullivan should win, it was quite simple to vote for both, with one as the first preference and the other as the second. When the losing candidates’ votes get redistributed, the vote for one Mr. Sullivan would be transferred to the other one. As it turned out, Ms. Peltola won without redistributing anything because she had a majority of votes when first preferences were counted.

Now that the Democrats have 56 votes, they can alter the filibuster rules and lower the threshold to 55 votes from 60. The filibuster (which this journal believes is a disaster for democracy) is retained for the Senate institutionalists, while it is practically removed from consideration. Even is Pennsylvania’s John Fetterman (who is nominally a Democrats) were to cross the aisle, the hold on the Senate would remain.

The upcoming Congress is not going to get much done. The president will wield his veto pen frequently. That should not deter the Democrats. They should pass every wish-list item they can imagine. If the president signs a bill into law, great. If not, it is something to run on in 2028. It is silly, and it wastes time, but it is the way the US system works.

And if the Democrats do not do this, they could well lose in 2028.

Scroll to Top