
The presidents of the People’s Republic of China, the Russian Federation and the United States met for 90 minutes today in a pointless summit. While each had his own reasons for wanting the photo op, nothing of any import was actually decided. This is how Mr. Trump does diplomacy. He likes rubbing elbows with powerful men. The months of preparation that professional diplomats would normally undertake are left undone. For Mr. Trump, the meeting is important; what gets decided is not. This summit accomplished nothing in the way of agreements on solving common problems. All it did was underline that the US is in relative decline while China is relatively in the ascendant. Russia was just lucky to be included.
The Los Angeles Times got it right when it stated:
The meeting, conceived not by policymakers but by Trump and Putin themselves, had a fractured agenda, with each leader coming to the table with divergent interests and different stakes.
But the image of Trump standing alongside Putin and Xi — then sitting alone with the two of them, at a great round table in a cacophonous hall — was itself the culmination of a decade of his foreign policy thinking, a great man theory of diplomacy that has broken with American tradition, elevating authoritarian leaders over democratic allies.
The US released a document that detailed the talks.
- China, the US, and Russia have “committed to reform the UN” to respond more effectively to global challenges
- The countries “plan to increase” the production and supply of petroleum products
- They agreed that the International Criminal Court and other similar entities “must not abuse their jurisdiction”
- The three countries “will conduct a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks” and preventing nuclear proliferation
This is a four-point nothingburger. Committing to reform means nothing. Planning to increase means nothing. Warning the ICC to watch its step is just a statement of policy from the three of them. Conducting a dialogue means nothing.
What Mr. Xi got from this was the status as the equal of the American president. “History tells us that when great powers are at peace, the world is secure,” Mr. Xi said. “When great powers clash, the world is in chaos.” Until the meeting, however, China was a great power only because the US was willing to accord it that status. Now, it is clear that the People’s Republic of China is the equal of the US, and might be ahead of it.
Mr. Putin, who leads a nation about as important as Brazil or Nigeria — regional powers at most, got to sit at the head table again. The two biggest challenges to US foreign policy of the last generation have been managing the rise of China and managing the decline of Russia. As Senator John McCain said, Russia is a gas station with nukes. It does not have a well-developed economy. It does not have an army that can drive down an open freeway to capture Kyiv. It does not have cutting edge technology any more. But for today, Mr. Putin can pretend he has Stalin’s mustache and Stalin’s standing.
Mr. Trump got nothing for the US, but he got a lot for himself. As chief groupie of the dictators club, he got his picture taken with two tyrants, and he thinks that makes him cool. He may get planning permission for buildings in Russia and China. He probably had a chance to cut an under-the-table deal with Chinese companies or Russian oligarchs. But for the family in Omaha who are facing $4 a gallon gas and higher prices at Christmas, he got nothing at all. Not that he tried.
