Bankers Low-Balled Anthropic Price

Artificial Intelligence company Anthropic went public yesterday in the biggest IPO in history. JPMorgan Chase led the US retail share sales and domestic marketing for Anthropic’s record-setting IPO, while Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley served as the overall lead underwriters. It was their job to set a price for the IPO and to get the stock sold. They succeeded in placing the $81.3 billion offering. Anthropic is now valued at around $1.27 trillion after Friday trading. It should have been more, but the banks made sure they got a piece of the pie, at the expense of the shareholders.

This happens with every IPO. Bankers want to make sure every share gets sold, and one way to ensure that that occurs is to price the stock below where it probably should be. If one believes $5 a share will sell out, price it at $4.75 to make sure. The fact that the bank also get shares (it is always written into the deal) does not matter. If the price spikes after the first trade, they make money. If it does not, they still get the stock.

Yesterday, Anthropic debuted on the exchange at $83 a share, the price the bankers set. Anthropic sold 1.27 billion shares of Class A common stock at $83.00 per share in its IPO — including the full exercise of the underwriters’ 147-million-share option — raising roughly $93.5 billion in gross proceeds. So, the company got $93.5 billion and regardless of what the price does, the company has $93.5 billion in cash. The price could go to $200 or to $2, but the money stays the same because the transaction is over.

But before the first trading day ended, the stock traded at $115.10 a share — a $32.10 increase. Anthropic got exactly none of that $32.10. The shareholders who bought first thing in the morning could have liquidated their position in the afternoon and booked that profit. Whether they did or not is irrelevant to the discussion at hand. The point is that someone was willing to pay $115.10 a share, but the banks priced it at $83. That is how Anthropic got taken.

It is hard to believe that anyone at Anthropic is upset by that. As of today, the people who work there and who had stock are probably millionaires or even billionaires. If they left some money on the table, they are not too concerned. And that is what the bankers are counting on. They got their shares as part of the deal itself. They were paid in stock for their services.

The Banker wrote today, “Last week, Wall Street lenders pushed for a higher valuation for Anthropic’s IPO because of heavy investor demand, even as analysts cautioned the recent AI sell-off would lead to lower fee income than for SpaceX’s blockbuster listing in June.”

Indeed, the Times of India noted, “Dario Amodei-led Anthropic has retracted back its IPO details the company sent to banks on November 9. As stated in a Reuters report, an Anthropic representative sent a copy of a securities filing to banks that shows that the AI company plans to sell about 867 million shares at a price range of $70 to $80 per share and eventually raise nearly $70 billion. However, Anthropic sent a follow up email saying details about the pricing were inaccurate, adding that it will update the filing later.”

The interests of the underwriters, Anthropic and the retail market are at odds. Anthropic wanted a high price, the retail guys a lower one, and the underwriters just wanted their shares. This is how IPOs work; they work best for the bankers.

Scroll to Top