
The United States has the most air traffic of any place on Earth, and air travel is the life blood of much of the economy. So when the entire system ground to a halt on Friday afternoon, it was a smidgeon inconvenient. This morning, the system is still not quite back in order. The cause appears to have been a hardware change from copper wire to fiber optic cable at one site that cascaded across the system, forcing the FAA to halt flights while it sorted out the system. The real cause, however, is gross incompetence. Most of the blame lies with the Trump administration, but previous government action going back to the 1980s figures into the matter as well.
Secretary of Transportation Sean Duffy is an Irish joke come to life. A former MTV reality star, he knows absolutely nothing about transportation. His partner in folly Homeland Security Secretary (Heimatschutzminister in the original) Markwayne Mullen was a plumber once upon a time. That is a great, blue-collar career, but it does little to prepare one for dealing with threats to the nation. They performed about as one would expect. The perfect moment came when they prepared to address the media on Saturday morning, and the microphone did not work. Maybe a sound check would have been in order. In any case, if either of them were honorable men, they would have resigned by now.
Yahoo! News reported:
Duffy said the outage started with work to switch lines from copper wire to fiber at an FAA site in El Dorado, Arkansas. When the new router there was turned on, a router installed about three weeks earlier in Amarillo, Texas, “started to flood our system as well,” Duffy said on ABC’s “This Week.” Both routers are being examined at an L3Harris lab in Florida, and the FAA is working with the FBI and other law enforcement, he said. Officials said Saturday they found no evidence of a cyberattack . . . .
On Saturday, Duffy said officials were working to determine “whether we had incompetence” by L3Harris Technologies, which owns and runs the network, or a faulty router. L3Harris told Yahoo News it is “supporting the FAA in its investigation” but did not address Duffy’s criticism.
The lack of evidence that there was a cyberattack means little. This administration is so concerned about avoiding blame that they may not be looking very hard. If Iran or Russia wanted to harm the US, hitting the FAA systems on a Friday afternoon is a pretty effective way to do it. Failure to stop such an obvious attack is, quite simply, incompetence.
If it was not a cyberattack, the incompetence charge remains. No IT professional worth his or her pay would update a system on a Friday afternoon. Such updates are done when the system is not at peak use, say Sunday morning around 3 am. If the routers was bad or if the IT guys screwed up is also irrelevant. Routers should be tested. Engineers should know how to implement the upgrades. Either way, it is incompetence.
Mr. Duffy, who was so concerned about the air traffic control system that he took his family on a 7-month road trip paid for by taxpayers, had more than enough money despite his demand for $50 billion more. The facts are that the Biden administration provided $25 billion as part of the infrastructure bill. Another $12.5 billion was in the “big, beautiful bill.” Mr. Duffy only spent a billion of that. It seems that that might be incompetence as well; it depends on the project manager’s timelines.
Yet, this problem goes back to the 1980s. Ronald Reagan fired the air traffic controllers in 1981, wiping out centuries of experience. Along came the personal computer and the information revolution that followed. The need for investment was clear, but the spending did not match the necessary digitization and later maintenance. Mr. Reagan hated taxes (except he raised them 12 times including the largest tax increase in US history to that date) and spending (except on the military which doubled the American national debt), so investing in the air traffic control system was denied the money needed to keep the system running on reasonably up-to-date technology. It is so bad now that the FAA uses pen and paper to keep tabs on some things.
While the lag between state-of-the-art and what the FAA had was small in 1985, it is huge now. Getting caught up will cost more than keeping current would have. That is the height of incompetence — being pennywise and pound foolish.
